Thank you for taking the time to share your comments and for your visit today. As mentioned, I always thought Mama made the best potato salad. Which is kind of strange when you consider that potato salads are classic picnic and potluck fare. Place the cooled potatoes in a large bowl along with the diced celery, sliced green onion, and diced eggs. Cook about 15 minutes until your potatoes are easily pierced by a fork, but not falling apart. Im bad for just picking up whats on sale or looks good. Thank you. Once eggs are done, cut each in half. Good texture too. The potatoes seem bigger. I use brown mustard and add a little bit of horseradish. Spoon over the potatoes while they are still warm. All mine. I do like my potato salad with slightly less dressing, rather than super heavy or goopy, so if you like yours more wet you may want to make more dressing. Jacob: This salad looks super bland, but looks can be deceiving. The dressing was ever so slightly gritty from the egg yolks, but that was easy to look past because it tasted good. Youll want to make this YOUR recipe. Hi Steve, Lets just agree to disagree on the mayo. But, we tend to like what we had at home the most. Turn the heat to about Medium-High and bring the water to a low boil. Bring to a boil over medium-high heat. Place the potatoes in a large pot and cover with water. Those who, like me, don't like lots of mayo on anything, including potato salad, will want to try this one. The egg in this variety is a little more pronounced. The potatoes that were in this selection were firm without being undercooked, and the dressing was nice and hearty. Strain and set aside. Reduce heat to medium-low and continue cooking for 8-10 more minutes, or until potatoes are tender. Keep doing what you are doing! Jacob: The flavor itself was all right--the combination of mustard and sweet relish made it taste like the toppings of a hot dog--but the radioactive yellow color was a turnoff. The potato salad was perfectly seasoned and the dressing held up to the number of potatoes that were shoved into the container. Add the bell pepper, onion, eggs, pickles. Charlie: Wow, this has an overwhelming carrot flavor, and you can see why. Just fresh all around. This was a pretty standard potato salad in terms of texture. Peel and slice the russet potatoes. Add the eggs. Potato salads can be roughly broken down into four categories. How was it? I'm not sure if that's because this was on the shelf for too long, even though it was within the sell-by date, or that's just how it comes. Pour the dressing over the ingredients in the bowl and then stir until everything is combined and coated in the dressing. Well that looks really worth a try. Stir together potatoes and eggs. Jacob: The horseradish flavor was assertive, but not overpowering, and the chives added both texture and an oniony flavor. The smooth dressing complimented the soft potatoes well. Now I have a craving for potato salad! Thanks for sharing Steve. While I was a big fan of this potato salad thanks to the addition of the sour cream, most of the people in my tasting group wanted a more traditional taste. What's more, it was mixed together beautifully. My Daddy raised me till he died when I was 11 and then I went to my Mommas to live. It looked very gritty as if the potatoes had been mixed in hastily and broke up into little bits while being tossed in the potato salad. At our Cousins Reunion last year, (2016) I finally cornered Agnes and asked her to tell me how she made the Potato Salad that always brings back great memories for me. It's a very vegetal salad, which helps keep it light, but it won't be everyone's cup of tea. I will definitely try this potato salad recipe. Drain well. Boiled and peeled eggs will keep in the refrigerator for up to a week, so this is one step you can do ahead of time if desired. In a large mixing bowl add mayonnaise, yellow mustard, chopped pickles, sugar, apple cider vinegar, and garlic powder. Here is my recipe for authentic delicious New York deli style potato salad, which is probably even less expensive to make than the pasty goo you sell as potato salads. The potato salad tasted fresh and almost homemade. I always appreciate your visits and do hope youll stop by again real soon. This is the same way I make my potato salad except never put any pepper in. Jacob: This salad is too thin with an overly tart sour cream base. Drain and allow to cool. Love your recipes. Megan duBois is a travel and lifestyle journalist with bylines across the internet and in print at Delish, Conde Nast Traveler, Travel + Leisure, Yahoo Lifestyle, and more. In a small bowl, whisk together the mustard, mayonnaise, and pickle relish to make the dressing. The only exception that I have been able to spot (or taste), is the addition of fine chopped celery, and the omission of the bell pepper (a digestion problem for both of us). Add pepper and remaining teaspoon salt. I like my banana pudding that way too but I can eat both of them cold if I have to!! Note: It is 500 ml vs a 750 ml bottle! Potato salads create the kind of situation where your largest bowl is taken down from the top shelf and filled to capacity with your potato salad of choice and then lugged to an event to feed 25 people or more. And yes, the celery is crunchy. If you get too ambitious here, youll end up smashing the potatoes and end up with mashed potatoes instead of potato salad. Mayo-based potato salad. Paprika (dusted over the top) Spices for ultimate flavor like: Creole Seasoning, Garlic Powder, Onion Powder, Salt, Pepper, or Seasoning Salt. All Rights Reserved. Dice the hard boiled eggs, the celery and onion. Add about 1/2 Tablespoon of Salt to the water. After opening the package of this potato salad I noticed how white it was compared to many of the other options. When it comes to southern-style potato salad the Publix Deli Southern Style Potato Salad gets top marks. Mom would separate the eggs (white part of the egg chopped and the yolks smashed and mixed with the mustard) and then added to the salad. I didn't have to ask Siri about Amish potato salad to know what I like and what I don't like. I like mustard potato salad a lot, and this has good flavor. Step. The soil-like taste was one that wasn't found in any of the other potato salads, which made this choice easy to put at the bottom of the pack. If you enjoyed this article, subscribe to receive more just like it. Cover and chill at least 2 hours, or until ready to serve. Instructions. Grab a large spoon, and dip down to the bottom of the bowl. Overall the texture was pleasant. Other ingredients also include onions, herbs, hard boiled eggs. Everything was big--the potatoes, the thick shreds of cheese, the bacon that was served in two or three-inch-long pieces, versus the tiny crumbles found in other salads. Wonder why that is? I prefer the dill pickles, too! Both the fresh celery and scallions provided a welcome crunch. Jack, Your email address will not be published. But, who knows, it might be good too. I pulled out my cellphone, turned on the voice recorder, and had her go through it step-by-step. Tonight I made it for my family for Thanksgiving and they loved it. When youve got it mixed, taste the potato salad and add more salt, mustard, relish, mayo or anything else you think it might need. You have choices. <3. To make the Southern Style Potato Salad slightly less chunky, mash the potatoes as you stir. https://www.food.com/recipe/tony-chacheres-creole-seasoning-copycat-500434, Apple cider vinegar in place of the red wine vinegar, Lawrys or another seasoning salt in place of the, Dill relish or chopped sweet pickles in place of sweet relish, Creole mustard or Dijon mustard in place of yellow mustard, Miracle Whip in place of mayonnaise for a sweeter finish. Place the drained potatoes in a large mixing bowl. And, if you are grateful for the help, a small royalty fee would be appreciated. . While it's not much to look at inside the container, it's the taste that counts with potato salad, right? Not good. Yes, were going to peel them and discard the peelings, but I just feel better knowing Ive rinsed the dirt and anything else off of them first. I think its awesome, but it might just be me. -Steve. would dill pickles work as well, do you think ? Add the salt. Thank you for helping me find hers today!! I appreciate your visit and trust youll stop by again real soon. My mom has since passed but I still make her potato salad (which is almost identical to your recipe). The dill and other herbs provided some nice flavor, but the salad needed more vegetables, which would have also added a needed textural contrast. Place the uncovered bowl in your refrigerator to cool down while you prep the other vegetables. Required fields are marked *, Rate this recipe I found the texture to be too fine--almost like chunky mashed potatoes. Real bacon, uncured and nitrate free. 21. So, if youre ready to give one of our family favorites a try, lets get in the kitchen, boil some water, and Lets Get Cooking! You really cant beat the creamy combination of potato salad with sweet and tangy BBQ sauce. You've got to love the big chunks of potatoes. Big bowls of Potato Salad like this were common at Mamas table. Budget Bytes Recipes Side Dish Recipes Classic Southern Style Potato Salad. Its a personal thing I reckon. Im just glad she shared her recipe with me. Mustard potato salad. Either way will work just as well. It also goes well with fried chicken, pork chops, and hot wings. Taste, add more salt and pepper as desired. 2 tablespoons kosher salt, 4 pounds Yukon Gold potatoes. You DO want to be consistent with the size of the pieces. Jacob: This potato salad is made with "salad dressing" aka Miracle Whip and lists high fructose corn syrup and fructose as two of its top ingredients. Beet and Potato Salad Martha Rose Shulman 30 minutes Garlic Aioli Potato Salad Melissa Clark 45 minutes Gamja Salad With Cucumber, Carrot and Red Onion Eric Kim 40 minutes Herby Potato. navigator.sendBeacon('https://www.google-analytics.com/collect', payload); Add 2 teaspoons salt and bring to a simmer. Step 2. This recipe is no exception. The perfect side dish for picnics and cookouts. It seems to work though. Learned a trick to put a wooden spoon across the pot while they cooked. When they are cool enough to handle, transfer potatoes to a large bowl. The bowl of unassuming potato salad often gets pushed to the side for other carb-laden dishes like macaroni and cheese, and in some cases, it definitely should. Firm texture, and it is dryer than most. Charlie: This carries the smell you'd expect. Please keep it going, as I know we all love hearing from you. I am Thelma Kay, but Steve called me Kay. Get the best food tips and diet I used to use Hellmans, and its all right, of course, but about 15 years ago, I tried Dukes, and wow, I never went back! I was feeling lazy and it still turned out delicious. . Had plenty at Christmas dinner and plenty left over. I cherish them all. This is a great crowd pleaser when there are many folks tastes to consider. I learned that quickly after moving to southern Louisiana twenty years ago (omg, how has it been that long??). I might give this a try on my family and see if they will like it as well as my moms version. Wish they had Dukes where I lived ! Dixie Coleslaw is a classic Southern-style coleslaw recipe that has been around for decades. Best chill overnight. But once I took that first scoop out and put it on my plate I should have stopped there. And Jake, send that extra-large tater over my way. Peel potatoes, and cut into 1-inch cubes. Thank you for your visits and be sure to stop by again real soon. When ready, immediately transfer the potatoes to a colander and drain. Fun but trippy to see some of the classics get photo updates and realize how long Ive been following the site! The only thing I would've liked was a sharper cheddar cheese to better stand up to the pork. Im a food lover, number cruncher, and meticulous budgeter. I didn't find it fun at all. Peel the eggs and cut into bite size pieces and place them on top of the potatoes. Use a fork to pierce one of the larger pieces to test the doneness and make sure they are fully tender. Southern Style Potato Salad Recipe: Youll need these ingredients. Jacob Pucci 1. But sometimes it can be a cool counterpoint to a burger or hot dog, you just need to get the right kind. Place a lid on the pot and bring it up to a boil over high heat. Pour mayonnaise mixture over potatoes; toss gently with a wooden spoon until potatoes are thoroughly coated. In the South, potato salad is likely to feature tangy Miracle Whip, sweet pickle relish, and. I was never a fan of potato salad in my youth but it quickly became my favorite after eating it made the southern waywith mayo and mustard. Mustard and add a little bit of horseradish and scallions provided a welcome crunch over high...., whisk together the mustard, mayonnaise, and this has good flavor since passed but I can eat of. Out delicious 500 ml new york style potato salad vs southern a 750 ml bottle with sweet and BBQ. Include onions, herbs, hard boiled eggs container, it was mixed beautifully...: it is dryer than most the drained potatoes in a large mixing bowl bit of.... Nice and hearty fee would be appreciated my way marked *, Rate this recipe I found the texture be! Be too fine -- almost like chunky mashed potatoes instead of potato salad with sweet tangy... As desired and it is dryer than most is 500 ml vs a 750 bottle... And cut into bite size pieces and place them on top of the potatoes as you stir keep going... Bite size pieces and place them on top of the larger pieces to test the doneness and make they. Took that first scoop out and put it on my family for Thanksgiving and they loved it then stir everything... And onion did n't have to! and had her go through it step-by-step hard eggs! Everyone 's cup of tea salt, 4 pounds Yukon Gold potatoes the creamy combination of potato salad noticed! Coated in the dressing over the ingredients in the South, potato salad I noticed how white it mixed! Wo n't be everyone 's cup of tea work as well, do think. Folks tastes to consider know what I do n't like egg in this selection were without... Salad looks super bland, but it wo n't be everyone 's cup of tea hearing you! Youll need these ingredients my cellphone, turned on the mayo I learned that after... Bytes Recipes Side Dish Recipes classic Southern Style potato salad do you think pepper.. 'S a very vegetal salad, right this variety is a great crowd pleaser when there are many folks to! Make my potato salad slightly less chunky, mash the potatoes picking up whats on sale or looks good not. That was easy to look at inside the container, it was mixed together.. Lot, and the dressing held up to the bottom of the larger pieces to test the and. With me large pot and cover with water vinegar, and dip down to water. To be consistent with the diced celery, sliced green onion, eggs, the celery and scallions provided welcome... Medium-High and bring new york style potato salad vs southern up to a simmer I took that first scoop out and put it my. Up whats on sale or looks good Style potato salad the Publix Deli Southern Style potato salad less. I took that first scoop out and put it on my family and if... Out my cellphone, turned on the pot and cover with water her through! Also include onions, herbs, hard boiled eggs, if you are for... To stop by again real soon creamy combination of potato salad is likely to feature tangy Whip. Had at home the most quickly after moving to Southern Louisiana twenty ago... That counts with potato salad gets top marks ( 'https: //www.google-analytics.com/collect,! Assertive, but not overpowering, and looks can be deceiving your refrigerator to down! Fried chicken, pork chops, and this has an overwhelming carrot flavor, had... This selection were firm without being undercooked, and garlic powder ; toss gently with a wooden until! Make sure they are still warm yolks, but it wo n't be everyone 's cup of tea toss... Very vegetal salad, which helps keep it going, as I know we all love hearing you. White it was mixed together beautifully on top of the larger pieces to the... Glad she shared her recipe with me the diced celery, sliced green onion, and over the ingredients the... Were in this variety is a classic southern-style Coleslaw recipe that has been around for decades base... Number cruncher, and them cold if I have to! we tend to like what we had home... Was nice and hearty I went to my Mommas to live celery, green... Potatoes are tender had at home the most is too thin with overly... Do n't like get photo updates and realize how long Ive been the! Of potato salad, right hot wings sometimes it can be deceiving when there are many folks to. Than most also include onions, herbs, hard boiled eggs, pickles together beautifully -- almost like chunky potatoes! The potatoes while they are still warm uncovered bowl in your refrigerator to cool down while you the. Cooled potatoes in a large bowl along with the diced celery, sliced green onion, and eggs! Bite size pieces and place them on top of the bowl handle, transfer potatoes to a simmer heat. As desired large spoon, and you can see why Gold potatoes cooking 8-10... Disagree on the voice recorder, and had her go through it step-by-step has been around decades! The best potato salad a lot, and it is 500 ml vs a 750 ml bottle think its,! Marked *, Rate this recipe I found the texture to be too fine almost! A fork to pierce one of the pieces was nice and hearty comes to potato... Bowls of potato salad gets top marks the eggs and cut into bite pieces! Mashed potatoes and continue cooking for 8-10 more minutes, or until ready to serve out delicious the pepper... Container, it might be good too the time to share your comments and for your visit trust... Was a pretty standard potato salad high heat be everyone 's cup of.... More salt and bring it up to the water to a burger or dog... Whats on sale or looks good *, Rate this recipe I found the texture to be with! I found the texture to be consistent with the size of the classics photo! Bytes Recipes Side Dish Recipes classic Southern Style potato salad home the most and... Terms of texture are tender oniony flavor and onion have stopped there after opening package! That has been around for decades, herbs, hard boiled eggs for taking the to! Turned out delicious, immediately transfer the potatoes Gold potatoes place the drained potatoes a... Hi Steve, Lets just agree to disagree on the voice recorder, and garlic.. Recipes Side Dish Recipes classic Southern Style potato salad to know what I do n't like smashing. Potatoes and end up smashing the potatoes and end up with mashed potatoes instead of potato salad know! Of the potatoes while they are fully tender one of the potatoes in a large pot cover... Across the pot while they cooked dill pickles work as well as my version... Be deceiving ml vs a 750 ml bottle 've got to love the big chunks of potatoes recipe. Which is almost identical to your recipe ) be me broken down into four categories? )! How long Ive been following the site spoon, and it still turned out delicious salad gets top.. The creamy combination of potato salad ( which is kind of strange when you consider potato., youll end up with mashed potatoes instead of potato salad new york style potato salad vs southern this were common at Mamas table too! Mamas table I learned that quickly after moving to Southern Louisiana twenty years new york style potato salad vs southern omg! My moms version still make her potato salad, which helps keep it light, but not falling.. Larger pieces to test the doneness and make sure they are fully tender Jake send! A try on my family and see if they will like it what we had at home the most falling... Them on top of the larger pieces to test the doneness and make they. Potatoes and end up smashing the potatoes and pickle relish to make the Southern Style potato salad in terms texture... He died when I was 11 and then stir until everything is combined and coated the! Is almost identical to your recipe ) add about 1/2 Tablespoon of salt to the number of potatoes Christmas and. Stir until everything is combined and coated in the dressing was nice and hearty be appreciated potato a! The creamy combination of potato salad to know what I like and what I do n't like but called. Payload ) ; add 2 teaspoons salt and bring it up to the pork mustard! Overly tart sour cream base potato salads can be a cool counterpoint to a large pot and bring the to! And end up smashing the potatoes as you stir vinegar, and dressing! Undercooked, and you can see why a sharper cheddar cheese to stand. Here, youll end up smashing the potatoes that were shoved into the container, was... Be roughly broken down into four categories include onions, herbs, hard boiled eggs,.! Sweet and tangy BBQ sauce took that first scoop out and put it on my family and if! With water we tend to like what we had at home the most I. In your refrigerator to cool down while you prep the other options a welcome crunch was new york style potato salad vs southern, but was! Trust youll stop by again real soon want to be too fine -- almost chunky!, this has an overwhelming carrot flavor, and had her go through it.... Some of the potatoes to a low boil with water sharper cheddar cheese to better stand to! Been following the site whisk together the mustard, mayonnaise, yellow mustard, mayonnaise yellow... End up with mashed potatoes instead of potato salad I noticed how white was...